Newsroom
March 17, 2017
NAFCU to DoL: Exempt CUs from fiduciary rule
NAFCU fully supports the 60-day delay in implementation of the Labor Department's fiduciary duty rule and on Friday urged the department to revoke the rule or, at the very least, exempt credit unions.
NAFCU Regulatory Affairs Counsel Andrew Morris, in an official comment letter, said that the Labor Department's final rule defining who is a fiduciary of an employee benefit plan under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 and the Internal Revenue Code should be rescinded because its complex requirements would discourage investment recommendations and restrict consumer choice.
The Labor Department recently announced a proposed 60-day delay of its fiduciary rule implementation date to June 9.
"Credit unions are different than most other types of financial institutions. Since the Great Depression, the credit union industry has defined itself as 'not for profit, not for charity, but for service,' and that shared philosophy has endured to this day," Morris wrote. "As financial cooperatives directed by volunteer boards, credit unions exist for the primary purpose of serving their membership – not for earning fees on investment brokerage."
Morris pointed out that the NCUA has traditionally stated that federal credit unions "may not act as brokers-dealers in securities or provide investment advice of the type that would render them 'investment advisers.'" While the Labor Department's rule covers these types of activities, it is also covers other transactions and relationships that "unfairly burden credit union activity with complex requirements and potential litigation risk."
As a result, he wrote, credit unions may decide that it is no longer worthwhile to recommend an investment advisory credit union service organization to a member or to make certain investment recommendations related to rollovers or transfers.
He added that the fiduciary rule's Best Interest Contract Exemption would impose a costly burden on credit unions since they would need to adopt anti-conflict policies before engaging in certain advisory activity.
"NAFCU believes that there is little merit in requiring credit unions to comply with a complex fiduciary duty requirement when there is minimal, if any, data indicating that potential conflicts of interest have negatively impacted credit union member service," he concluded.
NAFCU Regulatory Affairs Counsel Andrew Morris, in an official comment letter, said that the Labor Department's final rule defining who is a fiduciary of an employee benefit plan under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 and the Internal Revenue Code should be rescinded because its complex requirements would discourage investment recommendations and restrict consumer choice.
The Labor Department recently announced a proposed 60-day delay of its fiduciary rule implementation date to June 9.
"Credit unions are different than most other types of financial institutions. Since the Great Depression, the credit union industry has defined itself as 'not for profit, not for charity, but for service,' and that shared philosophy has endured to this day," Morris wrote. "As financial cooperatives directed by volunteer boards, credit unions exist for the primary purpose of serving their membership – not for earning fees on investment brokerage."
Morris pointed out that the NCUA has traditionally stated that federal credit unions "may not act as brokers-dealers in securities or provide investment advice of the type that would render them 'investment advisers.'" While the Labor Department's rule covers these types of activities, it is also covers other transactions and relationships that "unfairly burden credit union activity with complex requirements and potential litigation risk."
As a result, he wrote, credit unions may decide that it is no longer worthwhile to recommend an investment advisory credit union service organization to a member or to make certain investment recommendations related to rollovers or transfers.
He added that the fiduciary rule's Best Interest Contract Exemption would impose a costly burden on credit unions since they would need to adopt anti-conflict policies before engaging in certain advisory activity.
"NAFCU believes that there is little merit in requiring credit unions to comply with a complex fiduciary duty requirement when there is minimal, if any, data indicating that potential conflicts of interest have negatively impacted credit union member service," he concluded.
Share This
Related Resources
Add to Calendar 2024-05-03 14:00:00 2024-05-03 14:00:00 Plan Sponsor Attitudes Toward Retirement Plan Management and Fiduciary Outsourcing About the Webinar In January 2024, Pentegra conducted a survey of retirement plan sponsors and their perspectives on retirement plan management and fiduciary outsourcing. The survey measured how sponsors are using fiduciary outsourcing to help better manage their retirement plans. It also captured their perspectives on what outsourcing does to help them better position their plans and drive improved retirement plan outcomes. Key Takeaways: What is the full scope of your responsibilities as a plan sponsor? What is fiduciary outsourcing and how does it work? How does fiduciary outsourcing help reduce workloads and minimize risk? How can a credit union best position its plan to drive improved outcomes? Register Here Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Plan Sponsor Attitudes Toward Retirement Plan Management and Fiduciary Outsourcing
preferred partner
Pentegra
Webinar
Turning Lemons into Lemonade: Capitalizing in a Post-Banking Crisis Era
Strategy
preferred partner
Allied Solutions
Blog Post
Ensuring Safety and Soundness with AI
Management, Consumer Lending, FinTech
preferred partner
Upstart
Blog Post
Add to Calendar 2024-05-02 14:00:00 2024-05-02 14:00:00 Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans About the Webinar An Incident Response (IR) plan is crucial for guiding credit unions through major incidents efficiently and effectively. However, many IR plans lack resilience, making them less adaptable to the evolving threat landscape. Join us for our webinar Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans where DefenseStorm cyber experts Elizabeth Houser and James Bruhl will delve into the importance of resiliency within cybersecurity IR plans. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn how to: Ensure IR plan accessibility so that all team members with assigned roles are prepared for effective incident response. Conduct efficient and regular reviews to ensure roles and responsibilities are current, tools are relevant, and compliance requirements are met. Implement and utilize tabletops to regularly test the effectiveness of your IR plan. Enhance preparedness, efficiency, and confidence among responders. View On-Demand Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans
preferred partner
DefenseStorm
Webinar
Get daily updates.
Subscribe to NAFCU today.