Newsroom
NAFCU rep tells lawmakers consequences of 1071 rulemaking
NAFCU representative Mike Wilson, chief experience officer of Members 1st Federal Credit Union (Enola, Pa.), told lawmakers Tuesday how the CFPB’s section 1071 rulemaking could negatively impact credit union small business lending. Wilson was the only credit union witness on the panel before the House Small Business Subcommittee on Economic Growth, Tax, and Capital Access.
In his testimony, Wilson touted Members 1st’s member business lending, which loaned $350 million to small businesses last year. He also stressed that the credit union strives to provide extreme member service “because it’s the right thing to do for the communities we serve,” not because it’s required by law.
Responding to questions from lawmakers, Wilson noted the extensive training and investment that would have to be made to implement the rulemaking requirements – adding that costs would likely be passed on to consumers in some form – as well as the sensitive and “uncomfortable” position some employees may be put in to provide required demographic data.
“It’s not something that we want to put our entry-level associates in that situation of having to guess, whether it’s in-person or over the phone, it’s just not right. In addition to that, it could seriously compromise the data if they’re wrong based on assumptions,” Wilson said.
While NAFCU and credit unions are supportive of the CFPB’s goal to increase lending to women-owned and minority-owned small businesses, Wilson outlined concerns with the bureau’s proposed section 1071 rulemaking – which is expected to be finalized in the coming days – including:
- the definition of covered financial institution, which sets a low reporting threshold of 25 loans and “could drive smaller lenders out of small business lending due to the compliance costs that won’t be worth it if they do a small volume.” Wilson highlighted that the CFPB has acknowledged the significant compliance costs that could drive some credit unions out of small business lending;
- the small business definition, which does not offer a de minimis threshold to exclude some covered credit transactions from a financial institution’s loan-volume threshold. Wilson recommended the CFPB recognize credit unions’ member business loan (MBL) cap de minimis of $50,000 to protect small businesses’ access to affordable, high-quality small dollar loans;
- protected demographic information and visual observation requirements, which could threaten the integrity of data and “add unnecessary friction to small business relationships and give rise to avoidable, unreasonable fair lending risks;”
- one-time and ongoing compliance costs; and
- the 18-month mandatory compliance schedule, which “would be aggressive even for the largest, most technologically savvy credit unions.” Wilson reiterated NAFCU’s call for a phased mandatory compliance schedule to begin three years after the rule is finalized to give covered institutions time to implement necessary programs and tools.
Subcommittee Chairman Dan Meuser, R-Pa., shared similar concerns about the bureau’s small business lending data collection rulemaking imposing “burdensome new reporting requirements that would harm small business lending” and adding “an even larger regulatory cost burden to these small financial institutions,” as well as creating racial profiling concerns.
Throughout the hearing, other subcommittee members echoed these sentiments, with some also discussing the need for data to better inform policy and ways to reach underserved communities. All witnesses agreed that the section 1071 rulemaking would be costly and difficult to implement while harming relationship banking that could put credit unions and other small, community-based financial institutions at a competitive disadvantage.
NAFCU will continue to share concerns about the section 1071 rulemaking with the CFPB and lawmakers and advocate for relief for credit unions under the rule. Stay tuned to NAFCU Today for updates.
Share This
Related Resources
Add to Calendar 2024-03-26 09:00:00 2024-03-26 09:00:00 Ensuring Safety and Soundness with AI Listen On: Key Takeaways: [03:48] The regulators are very focused on fairness in lending especially when it comes to using AI and outside models. The industry is moving very fast. [08:25] Articulating a business use case and how partnering with a Fintech can support it is the first step in having a successful conversation with your board. [10:30] Talk to your account executive at your Fintech and have them help you overcome objections. [15:01] Plan for oversight. It is not set and forget it. Your regulators are going to want to know how you are overseeing that from a 3rd party risk management standpoint. [15:47] Have a handle on your reserves and capacity for lending and start small and grow slowly. Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Ensuring Safety and Soundness with AI
preferred partner
Upstart
Podcast
Help Ease Your Members' Loan Payment Concerns
Planning, Auto Loans, Research
preferred partner
TruStage
Blog Post
The Value of Risk Management in Cybersecurity
preferred partner
DefenseStorm
Video
Add to Calendar 2024-03-13 14:00:00 2024-03-13 14:00:00 Digital Assets in Credit Unions: What Are the AML Risks? The digital asset boom is upon us. Like it or not, you have to deal with it effectively with your members, credit unions are on the frontlines of crypto adoption. Even the NCUA has been providing more and more guidance on different aspects of digital assets. You need to be prepared. How? By understanding the core basics of digital assets (specifically cryptocurrencies) the risks that it poses to credit unions and how you can be better prepared to handle issues when they arise. In this webinar, Understanding the Digital Assets Boom, you’ll focus on the basics of digital assets, a background of cryptocurrencies and types, the regulations that are established and the proposals that are being considered and how to position yourself to understand all of these components and include them in your day-to-day roles. Key Takeaways Comprehend the basics of digital assets including cryptocurrencies Understand currently established regulations and what the future has in store, specifically in 2024 Identify and remediate issues that arise in your credit union Register Now $295 Members | $395 Nonmembers(Additional $50 for USB)One registration gives your entire team access to the live webinar and on-demand recording until March 13, 2025Go to the Online Training Center to access the webinar after purchase » Who Should Attend NCCOs NCRMs Compliance and risk titles Education Credits NCCOs will receive 1.0 CEUs for participating in this webinar NCRMs will recieve 1.0 CEUs for participating in this webinar Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Digital Assets in Credit Unions: What Are the AML Risks?
Credits: NCCO, NCRM
Webinar
Get daily updates.
Subscribe to NAFCU today.