Newsroom
NAFCU urges lawmakers to see through bankers’ false narrative on mergers; calls for Modern Glass-Steagall to protect consumers
NAFCU President and CEO Dan Berger Tuesday broke down facts for lawmakers ahead of today's House Financial Services Subcommittee on Consumer Protection and Financial Institutions hearing to examine financial services industry consolidation, competition, and technology in response to the American Banker Association's (ABA) testimony misrepresenting voluntary bank-credit union mergers.
"It is ironic that ABA is claiming the credit union tax exemption is a ‘new factor’ in banks looking to merge with credit unions," said Berger. "Mergers between banks have been occurring at a significantly higher rate with 5,000 mergers between banks occurring since 2003. Just yesterday, the Wall Street Journal examined bank merger data and found that bank to bank mergers were on track to hit the highest level since the financial crisis. ABA should tell policymakers the truth on why their industry is consolidating.
"During the hearing, we call on policymakers to look past the rhetoric by the banks and instead focus on how the banking industry can be safer for consumers. In their efforts to make profits, banks have ignored consumer protection laws resulting in $243 billion in fines since the financial crisis," concluded Berger. "Policymakers should consider creating a modernized Glass-Steagall Act in order to protect consumers and taxpayers from banks that are ‘too big to fail.’”
In addition, NAFCU's Brad Thaler wrote to the subcommittee Tuesday to further outline where bank lobbyists inaccurately represent these voluntary mergers.
In the letter, Thaler, NAFCU vice president of legislative affairs, noted that, contrary to what the banking trade association's say, bank and credit union mergers are typically a win-win for a local community that may lose its community-focused financial services, or even local employees and branches, if a mega-bank buys the local community bank.
"Credit union-community bank mergers often mean employees retain jobs and branches remain open with a focus on the members in the community," wrote Thaler. “These mergers also cannot occur without approval from both bank and credit union regulators."
Thaler explained that while banking industry trades have used the topic of mergers to attack the tax status of credit unions, they fail to explain that "these mergers are often purchase and assumption transactions and are subject to taxation at the bank level." Moreover, the credit union involved with the merger pays many of the taxes, such as local property taxes and payroll taxes, when the former bank remains open as a credit union.
"They also fail to point out that nearly one-third of all banks are Subchapter S corporations and do not pay corporate income taxes themselves," wrote Thaler. "These annual tax breaks for banks far outpace the annual tax expenditure of the credit union tax exemption."
In addition to responding to the bankers, Thaler outlined several of NAFCU's priorities under review by the subcommittee, including regarding regulation of fintechs, opposition to NCUA gaining third party vendor authority, the need for relief for de novo credit unions, support for all credit unions being able to add underserved areas, and support for the Credit Union Governance Modernization Act, H.R. 2311, which would make it easier for credit unions to expel members who threaten the credit union. Read the full rebuttal here.
Share This
Related Resources
Add to Calendar 2024-05-03 14:00:00 2024-05-03 14:00:00 Plan Sponsor Attitudes Toward Retirement Plan Management and Fiduciary Outsourcing About the Webinar In January 2024, Pentegra conducted a survey of retirement plan sponsors and their perspectives on retirement plan management and fiduciary outsourcing. The survey measured how sponsors are using fiduciary outsourcing to help better manage their retirement plans. It also captured their perspectives on what outsourcing does to help them better position their plans and drive improved retirement plan outcomes. Key Takeaways: What is the full scope of your responsibilities as a plan sponsor? What is fiduciary outsourcing and how does it work? How does fiduciary outsourcing help reduce workloads and minimize risk? How can a credit union best position its plan to drive improved outcomes? Register Here Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Plan Sponsor Attitudes Toward Retirement Plan Management and Fiduciary Outsourcing
preferred partner
Pentegra
Webinar
Turning Lemons into Lemonade: Capitalizing in a Post-Banking Crisis Era
Strategy
preferred partner
Allied Solutions
Blog Post
Ensuring Safety and Soundness with AI
Management, Consumer Lending, FinTech
preferred partner
Upstart
Blog Post
Add to Calendar 2024-05-02 14:00:00 2024-05-02 14:00:00 Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans About the Webinar An Incident Response (IR) plan is crucial for guiding credit unions through major incidents efficiently and effectively. However, many IR plans lack resilience, making them less adaptable to the evolving threat landscape. Join us for our webinar Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans where DefenseStorm cyber experts Elizabeth Houser and James Bruhl will delve into the importance of resiliency within cybersecurity IR plans. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn how to: Ensure IR plan accessibility so that all team members with assigned roles are prepared for effective incident response. Conduct efficient and regular reviews to ensure roles and responsibilities are current, tools are relevant, and compliance requirements are met. Implement and utilize tabletops to regularly test the effectiveness of your IR plan. Enhance preparedness, efficiency, and confidence among responders. View On-Demand Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans
preferred partner
DefenseStorm
Webinar
Get daily updates.
Subscribe to NAFCU today.