Newsroom
NAFCU shares core recommendations on subordinated debt
In response to the NCUA's request for comment on its proposal to allow low-income credit unions (LICUs), complex credit unions, and newly-formed credit unions to issue subordinated debt that operates as regulatory capital, NAFCU Wednesday expressed support for the proposal but urged the agency to reconsider the rule's complex procedural requirements that could discourage investors and issuers.
The issue of subordinated debt was included on the NCUA's fall rulemaking agenda and NAFCU has long advocated for a rule that would allow all credit unions to grow. Amid the coronavirus pandemic, the association called on the agency to fast-track this proposal and offer streamlined approval for secondary capital applications.
In the letter, NAFCU Senior Counsel for Research and Policy Andrew Morris noted the use of subordinated debt offers credit unions "an additional source of capital to manage risk, achieve growth, and maintain liquidity during times of economic uncertainty."
"In good times, subordinated debt can help credit unions embrace organic asset growth without fear of diluting net worth—a problem that is magnified in the credit union industry due to heavy reliance on retained earnings," he added. "During economic downturns, subordinated debt can serve as a buffer against capital losses and strengthen the resilience of both individual credit unions and the National Credit Union Share Insurance Fund (NCUSIF), and accelerate recovery."
Morris shared recommendations from NAFCU and its member credit unions to "help ensure that potential issuers are not discouraged by the high cost of adopting inflexible, securities-based requirements for offerings or a potentially lengthy, open-ended review process."
"Removing these barriers will yield a proposal that is viable for all parties to subordinated debt transactions while preserving the safeguards that have contributed to the success of the NCUA’s secondary capital rule," wrote Morris.
The recommendations include:
- simplifying the process for issuing subordinated debt, modeling it after the existing framework for secondary capital;
- evaluating subordinated debt applications within a shorter, definite, timeframe;
- not arbitrarily limiting approved applications to a one year "use-by" date; and
- not prohibiting credit unions from behind both issuers and purchasers of subordinated debt.
Morris also shared the association's support for the rule, highlighting the core benefits of the proposal: Better options to guard against risk, a path to safely pursue growth, and regulatory capital flexibility that contributes to credit unions’ competitive viability.
Additionally, Morris urged the NCUA to consider other technical improvements and expressed general support for the proposed aggregate limits, with some modifications, on subordinated debt investments by credit unions.
More information on the NCUA's subordinated debt proposal can be found in NAFCU's Regulatory Alert.
Share This
Related Resources
Add to Calendar 2024-05-03 14:00:00 2024-05-03 14:00:00 Plan Sponsor Attitudes Toward Retirement Plan Management and Fiduciary Outsourcing About the Webinar In January 2024, Pentegra conducted a survey of retirement plan sponsors and their perspectives on retirement plan management and fiduciary outsourcing. The survey measured how sponsors are using fiduciary outsourcing to help better manage their retirement plans. It also captured their perspectives on what outsourcing does to help them better position their plans and drive improved retirement plan outcomes. Key Takeaways: What is the full scope of your responsibilities as a plan sponsor? What is fiduciary outsourcing and how does it work? How does fiduciary outsourcing help reduce workloads and minimize risk? How can a credit union best position its plan to drive improved outcomes? Register Here Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Plan Sponsor Attitudes Toward Retirement Plan Management and Fiduciary Outsourcing
preferred partner
Pentegra
Webinar
Ensuring Safety and Soundness with AI
Management, Consumer Lending, FinTech
preferred partner
Upstart
Blog Post
Turning Lemons into Lemonade: Capitalizing in a Post-Banking Crisis Era
Strategy
preferred partner
Allied Solutions
Blog Post
Add to Calendar 2024-05-02 14:00:00 2024-05-02 14:00:00 Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans About the Webinar An Incident Response (IR) plan is crucial for guiding credit unions through major incidents efficiently and effectively. However, many IR plans lack resilience, making them less adaptable to the evolving threat landscape. Join us for our webinar Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans where DefenseStorm cyber experts Elizabeth Houser and James Bruhl will delve into the importance of resiliency within cybersecurity IR plans. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn how to: Ensure IR plan accessibility so that all team members with assigned roles are prepared for effective incident response. Conduct efficient and regular reviews to ensure roles and responsibilities are current, tools are relevant, and compliance requirements are met. Implement and utilize tabletops to regularly test the effectiveness of your IR plan. Enhance preparedness, efficiency, and confidence among responders. View On-Demand Web NAFCU digital@nafcu.org America/New_York public
Mastering Resilience in Incident Response Plans
preferred partner
DefenseStorm
Webinar
Get daily updates.
Subscribe to NAFCU today.